If our readers are anything like this editor, you’ll be very good at keeping your negative emotions bottled up. Is this a good thing? Some might say yes, as it can reduce a lot of potential conflict. However, new research is suggesting that keeping those bad feelings bottled up can make us more aggressive.
The research utilized two notoriously disturbing scenes from the movies “The Meaning of Life” (1983) and “Trainspotting” (1996). Asking a selected group of test subjects to suppress or show no emotional reaction to the scenes, researchers discovered that more aggression was apparent during the second phase of the study. By contrast, subjects who were allowed to demonstrate their revulsion to the scenes were far less inclined to show exaggerated aggression during the second phase.
After watching the movie clips, subjects were all made to compete in an online “competition”, where they had to blast an opponent with noise. The group who were told to suppress their emotion during the prior movie screenings, on average set their noise level 1-2 points above those who were told to express emotion.
Researchers also tested the impact of lack of sleep on aggression. They discovered that those who were deprived of sleep reacted no differently within the test setting that those who were well rested. This demonstrated that fatigue has little impact on increasing aggression, which is a contrasting result to a number of other studies.
This research, published in the journal “Social Psychological and Personal Science” and partly funded by a grant from the US government, could have important implications for reducing violence. The study could assist in developing strategies to help professionals within the military or other stressful professions to cope and reduce violent actions overall.
Psychologists find the meaning of aggression
‘Monty Python’ scene helps research
Bottling up emotions can make people more aggressive, according to new research from The University of Texas at Austin and the University of Minnesota that was funded, in part, by a grant from the U.S. Army.
The study, published in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science, could have important implications for reducing violence and helping people in professions such as law enforcement and the military better cope with long hours and stressful situations.
The psychologists used a pair of classic movie scenes in their research. They found that subjects who were asked to suppress their emotions and show no reaction to a notoriously disgusting scene in the 1983 film “The Meaning of Life” and another in the 1996 film “Trainspotting” were more aggressive afterwards than subjects who were allowed to show their revulsion.
The research reinforces scientists’ understanding of the “ego depletion effect,” which suggests people who must keep their emotions bottled up — not reacting to a difficult boss at work, for example — are more likely to act aggressively afterwards — by yelling at their children, perhaps.
Subjects in the experiment who were deprived of sleep before watching the scenes reacted no differently than those who were well rested. This suggests that fatigue does not make people more aggressive, as some previous studies have suggested.
“Our research suggests people may become more aggressive after they have to control themselves,” says co-author Arthur Markman, a psychology professor at The University of Texas at Austin “Whatever psychological mechanisms are at work when people deal with stress and then have to exercise self control later are not the same thing that happens when you’re tired.”
Markman wrote the study with Todd Maddox of The University of Texas at Austin and Kathleen Vohs and Brian Glass, both of the University of Minnesota.
Subjects in the study included U.S. Army soldiers, cadets at the United States Military Academy at West Point and other college students.
Half of the subjects were asked to remain awake for 24 hours before watching the overeating scene from “Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life” and the toilet bowl scene from “Trainspotting.” The others were permitted to sleep. Some of the subjects were then asked to watch the scenes without visibly reacting (monitors made sure they didn’t cheat) while the others were able to watch the scenes with no restrictions.
All subjects were then placed in a computerized competition in which they could blast an online opponent with noise. (In reality, there was no opponent and no one was blasted, though subjects thought they were doing so.) Those subjects who had suppressed their emotions while watching the movie scenes began the competition by setting the noise level at between 6 and 7 on a scale of 10 while the others set the noise level at between 4 and 5, on average.
Contact: Arthur Markman
Source: University of Texas at Austin